It’s time to take Mark Twain back from the Atheists.

Mark Twain, famed humorist and writer of the classics The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, is perhaps the most celebrated American author of all time. He is also a favorite of atheists and atheist Web sites, who claim Twain as one of their own. But is their faith in Twain misguided?

I stumbled upon the Mark Twain-atheist connection recently, when I went online to verify that a quote came from the author. I found Twain’s name and writings on one atheist Web site after another (Celebrity Atheist, anyone?) and it’s easy to see why non-believers are attracted to him. The author had a knack for writing sharp one-liners like this:

If Christ were here now there is one thing he would not be – a Christian.

While Twain was raised a Presbyterian, and his funeral was held in the local Presbyterian church, he spent much of his life highly critical of organized religion, especially the Christian religion he grew up in. For instance, Twain wrote:

There is one notable thing about our Christianity…ours is a terrible religion. The fleets of the world could swim in spacious comfort in the innocent blood it has spilled.

Twain was often equally hostile to the mixed messages he found in the Bible. He saw the books not as the word of God, but as works of pure fiction:

I believe that the Old and New Testaments were imagined and written by man, and that no line in them was authorized by God, much less inspired by Him.

And while Twain claimed to believe in “God the Almighty”, he also went so far as to say, “If there is a God, he is a malign thug”. Yet, what this and the other cherry-picked quotes you’ll find on the atheist Web sites don’t reveal are Twain’s more nuanced statements on the subject. Take this passage:

I am plenty safe enough in his hands; I am not in any danger from that kind of a Deity. The one that I want to keep out of the reach of, is the caricature of him which one finds in the Bible.

Read the first part of that statement and it’s clear that Twain had developed his own concept of the Almighty, one that was at odds with the God of the Old Testament. He appears to have believed in a just and loving God, which is further evidenced by the quote below:

I think the goodness, the justice, and the mercy of God are manifested in His works: I perceive that they are manifested toward me in this life; the logical conclusion is that they will be manifested toward me in the life to come, if there should be one.

So Twain even leaves open the idea of an after-life. In other instances, his tone softens to the point that he actually seems to see the value of organized religion, even if its benefits don’t relate directly to him:

I am not able to believe one’s religion can affect his hereafter one way or the other, no matter what that religion may be. But it may easily be a great comfort to him in this life–hence it is a valuable possession to him.

There’s another interesting fact about Twain, that you also won’t read about on the atheist Web sites. Late in life he spent over a dozen years researching and writing a book about a Catholic saint—the legendary Frenchwoman Joan of Arc. The book is titled Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc and it was his last major work, completed just a few years before his death. He claimed this book was his personal favorite and his best work, writing:

I like Joan of Arc best of all my books; and it is the best; I know it perfectly well. And besides, it furnished me seven times the pleasure afforded me by any of the others; twelve years of preparation, and two years of writing. The others needed no preparation and got none.

What did Twain see in this farm girl turned legendary leader, who claimed to be personally directed by the voice of God and who regularly spoke with angels? Certainly, the core religious beliefs of Joan of Arc were very different from his own, but after reading excerpts from the book, it becomes quickly apparent that Twain holds his subject in high esteem:

She was deeply religious, and believed that she had daily speech with angels; that she saw them face to face, and that they counseled her, comforted and heartened her, and brought commands to her direct from God. She had a childlike faith in the heavenly origin of her apparitions and her Voices, and not any threat of any form of death was able to frighten it out of her loyal heart. She was a beautiful and simple and lovable character.

And therein lies the enigma of Mark Twain. He hated organized religion, saw the Bible as a book of dubious value and while he appeared to believe in God, wrote little positive on the subject. Yet he spent over a decade of his life writing about a women who claimed to be in regular contact with the Divine, and he did not write a single disparaging word about her saying:

She is easily and by far the most extraordinary person the human race has ever produced.

Perhaps Mark Twain is not the man the atheists think he is.

Earlier this month, the Mark Twain House & Museum in Hartford, Connecticut, had an exhibit on “Spiritualism, Séances and Sam”. It seems that Twain’s wife was a fan of séances and Twain himself occasionally sat in on the proceedings. Asked to explain Twain’s take on the spirit world, a curator at the museum, Mallory Howard, said: “He was always trying to figure out an answer without ever coming to a conclusion.”

And that possibly explains Twain’s motives best—he was just trying to figure things out. He was a man of contradictions who while quick to deliver a humorous and acerbic barb about religion and God, spent the twilight years of his life studying and writing about Joan of Arc, a woman for whom God was the primary reason and motivation for her existence.

Twain may have been like many of us spiritually-minded individuals, who shun organized religion and find little of value in the Bible—yet believe there is a greater life force, what some people call God, out there. We seek it ourselves and while we may come up short, we admire those who seem to have tapped into this force in such a meaningful and powerful way.

This post previously appeared on my Patheos Wake Up Call column, October 22, 2014.


3 responses to “It’s time to take Mark Twain back from the Atheists.

  1. You can have Mark Twain, we will keep his writings that are critical of religion

  2. How does Twain’s fascination with Joan of Ark, evidence him having a belief in a god? (The logical implication of your conclusion being that an atheist can’t be interested in spirituality, or persons who hold beliefs about god different from their own.)

    I don’t think this is your intent, but the whole tone of your conclusion seems to be the exact same as atheists trying to claim Twain as an atheist. It’s a common form of egocentrism to read our own beliefs into others.

    The term god carries with it a lot of baggage, and it’s not uncommon for us to place our own image/definition of god in place of someone else’s, when they use the term god.

    From a broad reading of Twain’s work it is clear that he was: culturally, but not actually Christian. That he was antagonistic towards organized religion, and that his professed belief seem to indicate atheistic leaning deism, of the American tradition. His participation and interest with the occult is based on its widespread popularity at the time, as well as an interest in the spiritual. And his lack of outright declared atheism, may be a product of the overt animosity towards atheism that existed at the time of his life.

    It’s important to note that most of the quotes you pulled don’t really support a personal belief in god. The ones that do don’t suggest anything more than a vague and ambiguous deistic notion of nature’s god, which many would argue is if not a form of soft atheism, at least only a step removed.

    Once you start stripping the god concept of form, it ceases being the same claim. As god ceases to have form, belief in it ceases to have actual consequences. This is supported by claims such as, “I am not able to believe one’s religion can affect his hereafter one way or the other, no matter what that religion may be.” What Twain indicates is a lack of belief that faith alone will determine one’s final end. This isn’t evidence of a belief in god, but merely a lack of belief in a god that cares enough to reward faith and punish disbelief.

    Deism creates an intellectual gateway into atheism. As god looses form and direct intervention/impact on the world, the rational for belief also decreases. God ceases to be an active being, and becomes a behind the scenes push on natural occurrences.

    The only quote that seems to support the conclusion that Twain believed in god is taken from a parody of the Apostle’s creed. “I think the goodness, the justice, and the mercy of God are manifested in his works:”

    You might as well have just pulled the first line of the prayer, “I believe in god the almighty,” and left it at that. This is not necessarily an expression of Twain’s personal beliefs, but a published piece clearly intended as parody of Christian belief.

  3. Thanks for your comment. I can not disagree with much you have said, but know that the intent of my argument here was to pull Mark Twain back to the hazy middle ground, between Christian and Atheist, where I believe he belongs. Religion and God pose an easy target for a humorist like Twain and I believe he took those pot shots gladly. But it’s more difficult to comprehend his decade-plus devotion to the study of Joan of Arc. For me, her single most compelling characteristic is not her fearlessness or leadership qualities, but from where these traits originated–her belief that she was being guided by something greater than herself or in her mind, God. It’s not a big stretch to believe that Twain also admired these qualities, in particular her belief in something greater than the self. ~Tom

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s